Will Reducing MCA Payments Be Enough? How We Test Whether a Business Can Recover

Financial advisor analyzing cash flow projections and debt service coverage ratios for MCA restructuring

When a business comes to us with several merchant cash advances, the owner usually wants one thing: lower payments. The daily or weekly withdrawals are too high, cash is disappearing faster than the company can replenish it and the immediate objective is to get the payments reduced. That may be exactly the right move. But before we consider what each funder might accept, we want to know whether reducing the MCA payments would actually leave the business healthy enough to recover.

A Rough Test: Cutting the MCA Payments in Half

One rough benchmark is to cut the MCA payments in half and see what the company looks like afterward. Fifty percent is not a standard concession, and it is not a prediction of what creditors will agree to. It is simply a useful way to test whether the operating business has enough room for a negotiated solution to work. If the company still cannot support its obligations after a substantial reduction in the MCA burden, then the problem is larger than the existing payment schedule.

Start Your Free Debt Relief Plan Now

Connect with experts who help businesses get back on track.

No obligation. Available same-day.

We are looking at total debt service, not just the MCA stack. The senior loan still has to be paid. Any equipment debt, term debt, revolver requirements or other fixed obligations still exist. The revised MCA payments sit on top of that structure, and the question is whether sustainable cash flow can cover it all while leaving enough margin for the company to operate normally. A business that moves from a deeply negative debt-service coverage ratio to something barely above 1.0 has improved its position, but it has not necessarily created a workable recovery plan. On paper, the scheduled payments may now fit. In practice, the company may still have no room for a slow customer, a payroll week that falls before collections, an inventory build, an equipment repair or any of the ordinary variability that operating companies deal with every month.

The Shortfall the Debt Schedule Doesn’t Show

That analysis becomes more revealing once we stop looking only at the debt schedule and start looking at everything else the company has been carrying.

By the time MCA payments have become clearly unsupportable, the shortfall has often already migrated into other parts of the business. Vendors may be well past their normal terms. Taxes may have been deferred. Inventory may be running below the level required to support normal sales. Maintenance and capital spending may have been postponed. Owners may have made periodic contributions to cover payroll. The company may still be current on most of its debt while the operating cycle underneath it has been deteriorating for months.

Accounts Payable as Hidden Borrowing

Accounts payable is often one of the best places to see that.

Suppose a company used to owe its suppliers about $300,000 at any given time and now owes them $650,000. That extra $350,000 isn’t just a number on the books. It’s money the business kept by paying suppliers late, in effect an unofficial loan from its vendors, and it’s often how the company kept up with its MCA payments. So the business can look like it can afford more debt payments than it really can, because its suppliers have been covering the gap.

That matters in a workout because those suppliers do not necessarily continue doing so indefinitely. Some will tolerate stretched terms if they believe the relationship is worth preserving. Others will demand catch-up payments. A critical vendor may move from 30-day terms to COD. Another may reduce the amount it’s willing to ship. A manufacturer can still have profitable orders and a full production schedule but find itself unable to buy the material required to fill them. A distributor can still have healthy demand and good gross margins but need substantially more working capital simply because suppliers are no longer extending the credit they used to provide.

A negotiated MCA payment that looks supportable before those changes can become unsupportable very quickly afterward.

Testing the Assumptions Behind the Forecast

That is why we don’t take a forecast at face value just because it shows enough cash to cover the revised debt payments. We want to know what the forecast assumes about vendors, taxes, inventory, payroll, maintenance and working capital. If the model only works because accounts payable remains badly stretched, taxes continue to age or inventory stays below normal levels, then the company has not really reached a stable position. It has simply shifted the remaining shortfall away from the MCA creditors.

The same thing happens when you look at whether the business can cover its debt payments. If only a little cash is left after paying the new, lower MCA payments, that can look like enough. It isn’t once you factor in everything the business has to catch up on. A company coming out of serious MCA trouble usually needs breathing room to pay down overdue supplier bills, restock inventory, deal with back taxes, rebuild a cash cushion, get to repairs it put off and handle customers who pay late. How much room it needs depends on the company, but every business needs enough cash left after all its debt payments to begin behaving like a normal operating company again.

When Lower Payments Leave Room to Recover—and When They Don’t

Sometimes the cut-in-half test gives a good answer. We may model a big reduction in MCA payments and find that the business can comfortably afford its total debt payments, start paying suppliers on normal terms again, rebuild its cash and still handle an ordinary slow month. In that case, negotiating lower payments over a longer period can be a sensible restructuring tool, because the relief does more than shrink the payment. It frees up enough cash for the business to recover.

The harder cases are those where even a substantial reduction only brings the company to the edge of supportability. Those businesses often look deceptively close to a solution. Management may say that if the withdrawals come down, everything will be fine. The numbers may show that the company can technically make the revised payments. But when we add back the aged vendors that have to be dealt with, the taxes that cannot continue carrying, the inventory that has to be replenished and the working capital the operation needs to function, there is very little left.

At that point, the issue is not whether a creditor is willing to negotiate. The issue is whether the structure being negotiated is worth using the company’s remaining time and liquidity to pursue.

The Runway Question: Time and Liquidity

That timing question becomes important because businesses in MCA distress frequently have less runway than management realizes. A company can still be open, still making sales and still current with some or all of its creditors while operating with only a few weeks of practical liquidity. The shortage may be hidden in stretched AP, delayed taxes, reduced inventory and owners filling periodic gaps. Once those accommodations stop being available, the distance between an apparently functioning company and an actual default can be very short.

We want to know that before negotiations begin. So we stress-test the next few weeks. What happens if one MCA funder keeps withdrawing at the current rate for another two weeks, a large customer pays 10 days late, a key supplier demands a catch-up payment before it will ship or the bank cuts how much it will lend? If the business can still make payroll and keep operating through those ordinary setbacks, it has time to negotiate. If it can’t, the fact that creditors are willing to talk doesn’t tell us much.

A funder can be cooperative and still be too slow for the company. A creditor that is willing to approve a modification in thirty days may be offering a perfectly reasonable accommodation, but that does not help much if the borrower has ten days of working capital left. The business must remain functional while the process is underway, and creditor timing rarely aligns with the company’s cash needs.

Once default begins, the environment can change quickly. Operating accounts and receivables can come under greater pressure. Creditor behavior can become more aggressive. A senior lender may become more concerned about collateral deterioration or the effect of junior creditor activity on the assets supporting its loan. The company that began by trying to lower MCA payments can find itself managing a much broader problem involving cash, receivables, working capital and creditor priorities.

Two Questions Before Relying on Negotiation

That is why we want to know two things before relying on negotiation. First, if a realistic re-amortization is achieved, does the resulting structure actually leave enough cash for the company to support total debt service, normalize the operating liabilities that matter and rebuild enough working capital to recover?

Second, does the company have enough time and liquidity to get to that result before default or creditor activity begins interfering with the operating cycle? Those questions are related, but they are not the same. A workout can be economically sound and still fail because the company cannot survive long enough to complete it. It can also be completed successfully and still leave the business with so little coverage that the next ordinary disruption sends it back into distress.

We are not trying to negotiate the lowest payment a funder will accept. We are trying to determine whether a payment structure exists that the operating business can carry without continuing to finance the shortfall through vendors, taxes, depleted inventory or other emergency borrowing.

When it does, negotiated re-amortization can create real recovery space.

When it doesn’t, lowering the MCA payments isn’t enough. The business may already be so close to default that every remaining dollar has to be protected and spent carefully on the restructuring. The next decision has to come before creditors start going after the company’s bank accounts and the payments its customers owe it.

Wondering whether lower payments will be enough? Our MCA Debt Relief Guide explains the red flags to watch for, the risky shortcuts to avoid and how to regain control of your cash flow.

Robert DiNozzi
Robert DiNozziChief Growth Officer, Partner